Methodology

How We Categorize

Every action, vote, and public statement tracked in Civic Ledger is tagged with one or more topic categories. This page explains what each category covers, how tagging works, and how to suggest corrections.

Our Process

Meeting data is extracted from the official Transylvania County meeting minutes published by the county clerk. We use AI-assisted processing (Claude by Anthropic) to identify votes, commissioner activity, public comments, and topic categories from the raw minutes text.

Every AI-processed meeting is reviewed by a human volunteer before publication. The reviewer verifies vote counts, commissioner attributions, and category tags against the source document.

Some items naturally span multiple policy areas. A discussion about courthouse renovation costs, for example, might be tagged with both Infrastructure (the building project) and Fiscal Policy (the budget implications). We apply multiple tags when the substance of the discussion clearly touches multiple domains.

The 11 Topic Categories

account_balance_wallet

County budget decisions, tax rates, revenue sources, and financial planning. Includes property tax discussions, sales tax referendums, fee structures, debt management, and grant funding.

Examples from meetings

FY27 budget strategy with no tax increaseQuarter-cent sales tax referendum timingFederal PILT funding advocacy$7M landfill grant savings
school

Public school facilities, capital improvement projects for education, and coordination between the county and school system on building needs.

Examples from meetings

NCDPI review timelines for school capital projectsRosman old gym structural issuesVirtual instructional day waivers for WNC schools
shield

Law enforcement, fire services, EMS, 911 operations, emergency preparedness, and cybersecurity. Includes staffing, equipment, and facility needs for public safety agencies.

Examples from meetings

SecureNC cybersecurity pilot MOU911 Center full staffing achievementSatellite Fire/EMS facility advocacyQuebec EMS station
construction

County buildings, roads, bridges, water/sewer systems, technology upgrades, and capital construction projects. Includes maintenance, renovation, and new construction.

Examples from meetings

Courthouse expansion estimates (~$36M)AV system upgrade for chambers ($183K)Capital project reporting improvementsBRCC campus projects
trending_up

Business recruitment, workforce development, tourism, and economic growth initiatives. Includes incentive programs and partnership with economic development organizations.

Examples from meetings

Business park developmentWorkforce training programsTourism marketing initiatives
visibility

Government processes, public accountability, meeting procedures, advisory board operations, open records, and inter-governmental relations. Includes NCACC activities and legislative advocacy.

Examples from meetings

Nonprofit grant SMART goals for outcome trackingAdvisory board minutes posted onlineSocial media misinformation clarificationCounty Planner vacancy hiring
eco

Land conservation, solid waste management, water quality, parks and recreation, and natural resource stewardship. Includes the county's significant public land holdings.

Examples from meetings

Solid waste rate studyParcel fee model for solid wasteLandfill operations and grantsPILT funding for county land
home

Affordable housing, workforce housing, zoning for residential development, mobile home valuation, and implementation of the county Housing Plan.

Examples from meetings

County Planner hire to implement Housing PlanDifferentiated tax rate on vacation/second homesMobile home valuation fairness
favorite

Public health programs, mental health services, social services, senior services, and community wellness initiatives administered or funded by the county.

Examples from meetings

DSS program updatesSenior center operationsPublic health department initiatives
cyclone

Response, recovery, and rebuilding efforts related to Hurricane Helene's impact on Transylvania County and western North Carolina. Includes FEMA coordination, infrastructure repair, and community resilience.

Examples from meetings

Bookmobile generator funding for emergency connectivityStarlink for bookmobile emergency use'Rising Above Helene' documentary screening
diversity_3

Cultural events, community organizations, historical preservation, recognition ceremonies, and quality-of-life programs that build community identity and engagement.

Examples from meetings

Veterans History Museum promotionBlack History Month remarksClerk Trisha Hogan's Master Municipal Clerk recognitionBookmobile service and programming
rate_review

Suggest a Correction

If you believe an item has been mistagged, misattributed, or is missing context, we want to hear from you. This is a community project and accuracy matters.

Email corrections to civicledger@proton.me with the meeting date, the specific item, and what you think should be changed. We review all feedback.